Tuesday, February 24, 2009

Grudge Match: "Grist vrs Env-Econ"

Ding ding, round one.

Its all kicking off over at the Gristmill and Environmental Economics Blog.

The problem as far as I can tell is over the definition of the word "snark" and the extent to which the said snark has substance or not.

As an economist I still like to see economists getting a good kicking and Dave Roberts does a decent job and raises some good points. Of course such abuse is like water of a ducks back to economists. I recommend all environmental economics students to read the Grist article by Dave Roberts and to formulate a defence (if there is one).


I particularly liked the first comment after the Grist article.

"economists are arrogant whores".


One certainly does not become an economist to be liked. TerraPass on the Env-Econ post suggests:

Greens also tend to oddly personalize the topic, dividing economists into “the good ones” and, I suppose, the hell-bound.


It would be interesting to know whether John and Tim and indeed myself are on a "highway to hell" or whether we sneak into the good category. I suspect Env-Econ have now been seen to have aligned themselves with the dark side.

High five anyone?

[Note: this post is entirely substance free]


.

2 comments:

John Whitehead said...

High five!

vaibhav said...

Ganesh Naik Felicitates Meritorious Students of Airoli

Meritorious students and senior citizens of sec 19 Airoli were felicitated at the hands of Thane Guardian Minister Ganesh Naik.
An event was held at sec 19 of Airoli were meritorious students of X and XII standard were felicitated at the hands of Thane Guardian Minister Ganesh Naik. At the same time, senior residents of the area were also felicitated by the Minister.....

http://navimumbai-ganeshjinaik.blogspot.com/2009/01/ganesh-naik-felicitates-meritorious.html

http://navimumbai-ganeshjinaik.blogspot.com